The Italian Job in New Market

Pizza is pretty damn good

Stopped here on a road trip and expected a pizza shop. Was kinda...but they also offered lasagna and other Italian favs. My S.O. ordered lasagna and I ordered spinach manicotti, both at extremely reasonable prices. Both meals were delicious and came with a hearty serving of yummy garlic bread. Was quite impressed with this impromptu stop right off of Rte 81 and would definitely recommend if you are in the area.

Hubby and I live in the next town over but never tried eating here. Stopped by yesterday and ordered mozzarella sticks (basic and the same as any other but still good) and a large Stromboli. The Stromboli was pretty big compared to other local Italian eateries. Flavor was nothing special but still tasted pretty good and filled us up.

Decent pizza, building was small but that didnt drag too much because it was a tourist trap place on I-81.

Food is good... delivery is slow. Took an hour for a sandwich and salad to go 4 miles.

Food was good. Stopped in on way through. Nothing extraordinary but have only been once.

Very friendly staff nice quaint small location the customers in the store or friendly as well

I won't be back the waitress Is God aweful.....I always leave a big tip...not this time honey boo boo... Have us a straw with pocket lint on it.... Asked if there was any specials ...she said no and I went up to the front and it was two slices of pizza and a drink for $4.75.... lazy lazy lazy.... I spend at least $ 50 to eat for my family never again man....

We usually place an order for delivery but this time we decided to pick it up ourselves. When I went to pick it up I wasn't acknowledged and even though I was first another customer was helped before me. That didn't bother me as much as the fact that both employees assumed that I didn't speak English for the way I look. The male employee said in a loud voice and perfect Spanish that he didn't speak any Spanish, they both laughed and he proceeded to go to back. having years of experience with customer service I know what the job is like so I always make sure to be polite and friendly and treat people with respect. I was highly disappointed and upset but still payed for my order and left. I hope no one else goes through the same disrespect that I did and I can definitely say I WILL NOT BE GOING BACK AND NO I DO NOT RECOMMEND THIS PLACE!

Great food and great prices

Good food

Went with a couple friends there. The bathroom was that of a run down dirty gas station bathroom, the menu had what looked to be a pube hair in it, and the waitress was incompetent. She failed to listen to our requests of no onions on my pizza or tomato and onions on my friends salad. They remade the pizza and the salad. We receive no apologies from the waitress and seemed she only cared to sit down in a chair by the cash register, and neglect the sit down customers. They need someone with a little more social experience, who knows how to listen and that can clean better.

Really great pizza. Our waitress was very nice and attentive.

Best pizza ive ever had

Kids enjoyed the pizza and spaghetti. Fast and friendly service.

Garlic bread with cheese was amazing. Since that was first bite all expectation was raised. Food was okay and great value. Get the garlic bread with cheese.

Good pizza and good service. Nice place to grab a quick bite on the way home.

Aside from the service, which was ok....the food was absolutely horrible..

Great place to dine. Food is delicious and service is great. Waitress is always helpful and delightful too be around.

Good food.

Cheesesteak sub was really good and the fries were good as well. The sweet tea was below average, tasted like they used tap water instead of filtered water. Prices are great.

The food is always excellent but fries are extra and need to be ordered when you order your sandwich. The waitress doesn't mention this, though, and I didn't see anything on the menu that mentions this. My dessert was ordered to go because we weren't asked if we wanted anything else. When the waitress brought it, it was not held upright and was leaking by the time we reached our car.

Service was great and the pizza was very good....cheese fries rocked too!

Got 3 steak and cheese told me 15 min 26 not a lot of meat and small tomato 2 on a 12 inch sub will not get there again

It's not that I disliked the place. it was okay, like the okay if I opened a box and heated the product up, or I took deli meat and put it on bread. Nice waitress.

Coming from someone who owned a restaurant I can say go somewhere else. Not worth it.

Got the 911 Buffalo Wings, lived up to the spice, but chicken was overcooked, like crunchy leather. Domestic bottles $3.00

The worst Gyro Platter I have tried. The menu say: This is the generous portion of lamb and this is what they delivered to the hotel. See pics. How they survive in the business?

We thought this was just a convenience store till some friends took us for supper. Since then we've introduced other friends to it. What it lacks in atmosphere it makes up for in good food at reasonable prices. The spaghetti is great and lots of it. I've had the eggplant parmesan and thought the eggplant was a bit tough. Plenty of choices though, so we plan on going back.

Excellent pizza and service

Not bad price not bad either

Best Calzone and Stromboli on the planet and the price is great too. We search the world for something close to as good as the Italian job and pretty much have given up. Part of the joy of camping in the blue ridge is getting to eat here.

Stopped off the highway on 15 July 2018. Great service, quality pizza and good prices! Loved it!

They have great food can't wait to go back again and good prices

Great place. Friendly. Good service. Good and reasonably priced food. I love the Philly cheese sub. Pizza is good, too.

Good food, staff is awesome

Decent pizza. Average wings. Too few fried mushrooms. Good service. Counter person was friendly and welcoming.

I stopped for gas on this exit on the way back to Florida and saw this place across the street. The place was small and looked a bit dumpy but looks were deceiving. I went in and ordered a large pizza to go. First off, it was $10 which I thought was cheap. As I waited for the pizza, I was thinking there is no way this is gonna be good pizza. Well, I eat my words.. this pizza was one of the best tasting and looking NY style pizzas I’ve ever eaten. I was blown away. It was perfect, sauce and cheese and crust were all just right. I am somewhat of a pizza connoisseur and am always looking for good NY pizza. I have a few favorites in FL but this was better. I am still thinking about this and wish I bought a few since I won’t be up that way again for years probably. Don’t change a thing, I’ve eaten at so many pizza places here and there and yours is awesome! I’ll be back if I ever make it up that way.

I like subs better than pizza. Try a couple for yourself. You'll probably come back.

The Steak Subs and Cheese Fries were fantastic!

Food is good but, we typically order delivery. Sometimes it takes forever to get someone to answer the phone. On multiple occasions I’ve received someone else’s food or only part of my order. It’s bad when I wait an hour to get my food and half of it is missing, or it’s cold, or a large salad has less in it than a small side salad. Seems that this trend has been increasing lately. I wish there was another option in this town.

Great pizza and great service there.

Terrible place to order delivery from. Will take them an hour to get your order and it’ll be cold, soggy and gross.

Small little place. We ordered pizza. Very good flavor unfortunately, it was almost cold when it came to our table. Will try place again cause pizza was good.

Bad pizza ok calzone

Friendly staff, robust menu, food was amazingly delicious! Prices were very reasonable. We will definitely be back.

Most times the little hole in the wall places are the best. That holds true in this case. They definitely know their way around a sandwich. Great Sandwiches!!

I really liked the hot subs there 🖒

Placed delivery order, both subs that we order came wrong. What we requested on our subs and what we received was totally different. I keep saying I am never going to order from there because this happens all the time. I feel like I just threw 25.00 out the window. Subs were nasty!

We stopped for a late lunch. Counter person was very pleasant. Pizza was delicious and service was quick. Would definitely recommend if traveling on Rt. 81.